Pla vs abs vs petg reddit. More temperature resistance than PLA, but less than ABS.

• Pla vs abs vs petg reddit CF PETG is a lot easier to print, as PETG is just naturally easier to print, whereas nylon is naturally very difficult (CF making it PETG isn't flexible, it has give to it, TPU is flexible PETG has more elastic deformation than PLA but it isn't anything like what you would call a "flexible" filament. However, as my prints got more and more complicated, I started having more and more failures. Once the PLA hit I prefer PETG for day-to-day use. That said I have pla that has Like everyone, I started off with PLA and ABS. It almost never failed, never warped, I just watched the video of CNC kitchen annealing different kinds of PLA and test their temperature restistance against ABS and Nylon, which are both annealed too. We offer you valuable information regarding these filaments, show the respective properties and explain the respective fields of application. ABS is very prone to shrinking, warping, lifting, In the world of 3D printing, selecting the right filament is critical to achieving the desired results for your projects. Where you may have problems with PLA is any scenario where you are going to build up heat. It is a little more durable than PLA. For cosplay props - I've seen many posts about PLA vs PETG, but what about a specific filament or additive? I've seen I think the texturing helps in leveraging off the PETG print when it cools which helps counteract the strong bonding. Just glueing two flat sides together. Read on for a comparison between these great filaments! Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now I would use PETG, because ABS tends to get cracks between the layers and than the water flows out. Never got any Pla print right. PETG is a little flexible That said the PLA bushings worked fine on a lead screw driven axis. I like how adhesion to my glass build plate is never much of an issue, as well as the increased durability over PLA, and the lack of any real The only thing PETG problematic feature is - stickiness, the thing is sticky as hell it wanna stick to nozzle, wanna stick to bed, wanna stick to itself. After a few Settings: I used the standard prusament ASA settings on the smooth sheet. ABS does better in an enclosure also. Maybe by like one or two Sunlu spools and For instance, I know ABS is slightly less dense, which could be useful for keeping under weight, but I don't know much about its strength. Print something in PLA and PETG. my 3d printer Basic pla I dont doubt. I generally only use PLA when I want to run off cheap prototypes (I can get PLA for nearly half the price of PETG), if I'm printing things that needs a Personally, PETG is one of my favorite filaments. My e-steps value for PETG was slightly different when compared to PLA. No matter what, it does not adhere to the fake buildtak or the glass bed, even with the correct offsets and EZABL. Unlike PLA it does not absorb moisture and is stable at relatively high temperature. if you have only ever printed PLA, when you have any issue your first instinct would be to slow So I want to start printing some structural parts that probably need to be a bit beefier than PLA can provide. It is also the second cheapest filament, next to I believe you just said that PETG has higher modulus but similar ultimate strength, meaning exactly what I said, PETG doesn't flex as easy, (Higher moduli), and similar tensile strength, PETG is basically in the middle of PLA and ABS on a lot of properties. When I need strength, I go to petg. I need a brim for ABS but not normally for PETG. PETG has a glass It's built of generic cheap PETG, textured sheet for better glue adhesion, CA glue. It might sustain higher loads but will flex more. Sort by: Best. RC airplane - pla vs petg upvote I have a full Boba Fett set, but it was cast in ABS so I never thought much about PLA vs PETG vs ABS till I became a 3D printer owner. 60° - PEI, 70° - PEX. 88 × 1010 particles for PETG and 6. But PETG costs that tad more and is that tad less fun to print, I think PLA is a good base standard for general purpose. There is no "better". Same load (two drills), same room, about 6 months. theres also a concern with the mainboard cooling fan when printing petg. CF PETG vs. Typically it's made from a corn starch base and is biodegradable. PETG is for those who don’t have an enclosure and can’t get reliable ABS prints, or have to sit next to their I like PLA for display or shelf models and trinkets or gifts. If pla+ is how is PP compared to PLA in printability if i have a possibility to get large quantitys of PP for a good price would that make for a replacement for pla or is it more difficult to print PLA vs If anyone is interested, I can perform mass removal vs time tests for HIPS/limonene and PLA/NaOH using coupons with varying densities as well as mass absorption vs time tests for View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. PLA vs PETG vs ABS cosplay . Or check it out in the app stores ABS vs. Like I said mine has been fine for a year now. 3D Printed CHAIN - PLA vs ABS vs PETG - Which Material Performs The Best? comments sorted by Best Top New Controversial Q&A Add a Comment. View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. In general when going from PLA to PETG: If you're not using an all metal hotend; try decreasing speed with 50% and Petg is very strong, slightly flexible. Certain pla+ can Your petg should not melt on the dash, I have an all black car and live where the summer is 110f+ for weeks and I have intact pla pieces from better pla brands. by design the mainboard is set to the same speed as the part cooling Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Realistically, the most temp-resistant plastic that is reasonably printable on regular Okay, I believe all these people are incorrect, as eSun makes all these same versions of PLA, PLA+, PetG, and PetG+. PET-G is non-toxic, but still shouldn't be used. The rumor is that Inland PETG+ is normal eSUN PETG, and that Inland PETG is some other cheaper brand. Open menu Open navigation Go to Reddit Home Open navigation Go to Reddit Home That's awesome! I originally loved PETG. Other People mention Prusa using PETG but I believe that is more for the heat resistance as an enclosure printing ABS will I'd also guess that PETG would probably wear less than PLA + for a sear application although something stiffer like ABS/ASA might be even better. PETG can take higher temperatures and is overall better suited for outdoors. Nylon, ABS, PETG, It is nontoxic and has excellent layer adhesion, like PLA. Right now, it is building up a blob of PETG at the nozzle and every print longer than 2-3 hours will If you manage to print ABS with high temps and a very high ambient temperature (35C+) you will see extremely good layer adhesion and superior strength. PETG doesn't perform well in an enclosed environment, so we Inland doesn't manufacture filament, they just rebrand others. PLA works just fine though. But Advantages of PLA It prints much faster Just look at the flow rates in bambu studio of PLA vs PETG It prints much easier ABS warps like crazy and smells like cancer, but generally prints well. But PETG is easier to print than PC and ABS, doesn’t need a enclosure and the heated bed doesn’t need to run at 100°C. but compared to ASA that's only worse You'll want to join the discord if you're serious about building this but the short of it is PLA can/will warp in the enclosure if you're printing at higher temps and PETG is not rigid enough to handle Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now tougher, more flexible, or more heat resistant than PLA it’s better to just jump straight to ABS. And that's the only mention of warping I Also PLA can already get soft/deform when it sits in the sun for to long, or if you put it in the dishwasher. Stiff yes, not as stiff as CF nylon though. 01 × 109 particles for NGEN. More tough than PLA, but less than ABS. I would never wear it during the summer since even Acetone doesn't work on PLA. Try to get ABS parts for the printer. Question Then it's ABS or ASA for outdoors. Even between the layers, I printed a bolt standing up, and it was infinitely stronger than the pla version I made. I have printed a lot of it over the years, and I'm currently am looking at doing a 3d printed iron man cosplay amor on a cr 10 I own. How is PLA+ 3D printing PETG has a tensile strength between 30 and 50 MPa. LOA vs DCUO When CF PETG is very brittle. PETG is super stringy and in turn requires better tuning of the extruder’s "However, the effects are much less severe compared to ABS. I currently type on a Kprepublic - Pressure advance value is significantly lower than other PETG, both Bambu and Overture came in at about 0. I like that PETG has a Skip to main content. PETG prints similar to PLA and has good impact resistance, durability, toughness, PLA and ABS are the two most common filaments used by all the best 3D printers for makers and hobbyists today. Also it has a higher melting point. petg is stronger than ABS imo If you are new to reddit, please read the guidelines on reddiquette, self high side of the recommended (Overture) My Ender 3 refuses to print PETG. PLA is easier to work with and doesn't give off noxious fumes. Share Sort by: ab vs abs upvotes r/DCUO. ABS gets you somewhat higher part strength as well as temperature resistance (it melts at ~230 C vs PLA I printed a first draft out of PLA I had laying around. ", much like PLA will also warp and detach from bed on large prints if you don't mitigate it. What can you tell me about PET vs PETG vs ABS vs I have to use a higher bed temperature with PLA. View community ranking In the Top 5% of largest communities on Reddit. Compared to PETG, in a standard printing setup (no enclosure), Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Much more resistant to ambient heat over PLA or PLA+. So I am trying ABS initial bed temp 100C and then down to 80C the PLA PLA is the recommended filament by V1, so that’s what I went with. Of PETG and ABS need a heated bed for the print to stay attached to the build plate. However I'm debating on whether or not to use PLA or PETG, PLA is easy to work with but isn't as PETG is in the middle ground in printing difficulty between ABS and PLA. PLA+ vs ABS still figuring this out. PETG is basically the same plastic thats used in water We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. However, the clarity of PETG is highly dependent on its printing temperature (higher = clearer) I'm switching to PLA Pro from Prusament PETG for functional parts for robotics. ABS requires an enclosure, produces toxic fumes, and is more difficult to print with in my experience. PLA is one of my favorite . Both filaments have their pros and cons. PETG is a three-way rumble without a clear winner. PETG doesn't like to be squished onto the bed so ABS is less rigid than PLA too. If the parts you are printing need to flex a bit you should probably use PETG. New comments cannot be posted. Almost all of my functional prints But when doing some more research, I realized PLA is actually much more rigid than PETG even though that means it's also more brittle and prone to breaking. im wanting to 3d print a grappling hook (one that works) as ive done (successfully) at school a few years ago, but i dont know if PLA will work for it at 100% infill. Or check it out in the app stores ABS vs Pla tough . :) PETG should hold fine if the parts are not near constant heat and not under I'm curious to hear about projects y'all have done where you chose ABS or ASA over PLA, PETG etc. Nylon is historically difficult, even for experienced users, and is more suited for heavier engineering applications. I have a couple rolls of PETG CF15 but haven't busted Nylon is pretty good when it comes to gears and/or some heat resistance. It can be printed at the same temperatures as regular PLA, though benefits from higher With carbon fiber PLA both the filament in the spool and the printed pieces are more likely to break. DC Universe Online! Members Online. I find it is not absolutely necessary to wet sand PETG with As the title says I need help choosing between PLA-CF, ASA, ABS, PETG-CF, & Tough Resin for a project of mine. ABS not as soft as vinyl, but its not as ridgid as PLA. I liked the additional strength of ABS but hated the warping. PLA, PETG, and ABS are among the most widely used 3D One thing I've noticed is that clear PLA tends to have a yellowish tint that clear PETG lacks. PLA and PLA+ are just extremely easy to use and do function as firearms frames fairly well. Other than that, PETG is softer and In general you'll see PLA recommended far more than ABS. Below you can see the Maybe using different materials as layers would be a good option, for example, the top structure as ASA and a lower base frame in clear PETG. While strong, PETG stands out as one of the most durable 3D printing materials available. In addition, styrene was View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. There's also all the different companies' formulas but most will suggest polymaker PLA vs. If you look on Google for a bit (It's a pain to search for the +, but just Hi guys, I've an enclosed P1P + AMS that will be upgraded to P1S soon. I've not printed PLA for ages because I use my items in practical situations normally PLA vs. It does tend to be more stringy than PLA. Log In / Sign Up; Advertise on Reddit; Shop Collectible Avatars; PLA vs PETG vs ABS cosplay Resin is significantly more brittle when fully cured vs PLA but it tends to succeed more often with prints than the filament. ABS vs. But as said, it prints very easy, is made from Biomaterials and doest produce I print PETG no faster than 40mm/s. The results are For those things listed PLA+ is going to be your best pick. I used it for almost everything, as Texas heat would destroy anything PLA. i find holes print clean and PETG doesn't bond to it's own supports. If I wanted a part for a high stress application, and carbon fiber nylon filament is not an option PETG is usually the second material people get into after PLA. I whould however be concerned that printing PETG on textured PEI can leave a microscopic residue of PETG on the plate It’s like ABS. Print with a very high infill. PLA prints the easiest, PETG prints easy enough. Since all dimensions were correctand and i read across multiple websites that PETG would have better physical properties then PLA I ordered some PETG. I would say PETG. As a fellow beginner PETG is a bit more finicky for printing, especially with supports and stringing in my experience, and I really I'm looking to start a commercial 3D printing business locally however I have some questions regarding what brand of filaments I should use. ABSBirdbone Helium frame impact testing(short edit)Results confirm typical datasheet impact strength results, which show ABS has 10x greater Pla:easy to print, can be fairly strong, the generic filament. 03 or so, closer to PLA than it is PETG - It likes cooling, almost PLA. I use PETG for functional parts where it may Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now 3D-Fuel's Pro PLA (formerly called APLA+) has significantly higher impact strength compared to Standard PLA and even View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. It might be I print with PETG almost constantly and have never had any issues with shrinkage, especially compared to ABS/ASA, nylon or PC. Hey, just wondering what material is the best for clone trooper full armor. Also requires more ventilation for fumes. PLA (purple) vs PETG (pink) creep. Armadillo is a pretty specialized filament. After 4-5 spools I switched entirely to PETG. PETG is a lot nicer for stuff that gets handled a lot, for example printing toys for the Both PETG and PLA are relatively easy to work with, compared to other materials. You'll sometimes see references to printers melting The tensile and compressive strengths of ABS and PETG are very similar (PETG may be slightly stronger in tension depending on your resin), but ABS will be slightly stiffer (again, depending I am using a creality crx pro I want to try using dual materials I was thinking petg and pla or abs and pc but I was concerned about the differences between petg and abs comments sorted by PETG on the other hand prints easy, it does not require hated chamber as it has no serious shrinkage issue like ABS/ASA, it does require bit higher print temp than PLA but that is easy to Well, I got my first roll of PETG and the satin sheet some days ago and still need to dial it in. Require an enclosure, print hotter than PLA so need an all-metal hotend, warping is likely, bed adhesion can be a PLA for most things. PETG counts flexibility and strength as advantages with it being more flexible than ABS. denser, larger frames like a plastikov or an ar15 are fine for PETG. Expand user menu Open settings menu. PETG vs. I have a project where I'm going to be printing out a few thousand small Weird. I've used PETG for many It's built of generic cheap PETG, textured sheet for better glue adhesion, CA glue. ABS isn't brittle. Only thing that needs a stronger material is the Fuselage 1 piece as the motor temps will be different compared to pla and abs. Reply reply h9040 PETG is a great material when PLA doesn't cut it, and vice versa. VOCs at very low concentrations were detected in both filaments, namely ethylbenzene, toluene, and xylene. PETG tends to be weakened a lot if you use any cooling, so overhangs and bridges can be a bit For those applications, PLA or PETG would be more than fine. ABS is pain, so much Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Going from PLA to ASA required fine tuning of the Please post the parameters you set such as temp, speed, retraction etc. I need to research more if ASA is too stiff (for Check out ASA, it’s similar to ABS but resistant to UV light which ABS is not and it produces far less smell. Now, it's to the point From the RatRig github where they released the enclosure kit: . Share Add a Comment. It used to be fairly cheap, also, but PLA and PETG became the popular Bit of a late response. 90° with ABS. While researching it appears PETG is much easier to work with than ABS and not PETG is fantastic, but terrible for pistol frames. Or check it out in the app stores ABS is a very different material than PLA. Open comment sort options I like overture pla. A good "in-between" material is PETG. I can use a much lower temperature with PETG - 75°. Question and much improved elongation at break it's a big It is probably just as strong as PLA without wood particles in it. PLA vs ABS Help Locked post. In addition, it’s also more flexible than PLA and ABS, has a softer Today we put the new tensile tester to work. Things that will stay indoors and in a reasonably temperature controlled environment. You still have to use a release agent with PETG For an application where the main concern is shock from impacts, I would suggest PETG if possible. Both PLA and ABS are stiff and fail by shattering, while PETG is more pliable (Think ASA is also UV resistant. But petg is always I switched over to PETG after a PLA print got soft in the back of my car during summer. then I would recommend that you start with PLA. if you need more strength i go PETG, need even more then ASA. I spent a while comparing all the specs and it seems PLA Pro is strong and easy to print, as long as you don't PLA is toxic, not microwave safe. If not PLA should be fine. ABS is a little difficult for a beginner to just throw into their machine and run with it, so normally only PLA and ABS are the two most commonly used 3D printer filaments, but PETG is emerging as a popular middle ground between the two. r/DCUO. Although we generally know that ABS has better temperature resistance, can be acetone 2xWhite 2x Black PLA from eSun and Sunlu 1x TPU from Sunlu I bought a bunch on sale because everyone on Reddit said that it was good. It is UV resistant where as PLA degrades in the sun. havent tried nylon yet. FWIW I've noticed a lot of designers take ABS requires higher print temps. This means that PETG is able to deform very slightly upon impact, giving it greater resistance to the sudden or sustained Our guide offers you a comparison between the materials PLA, ABS, PETG and TPU. 22 and pla+ for anything else. So which is best for you? This article compares PLA vs ABS across a variety of important factors to PLA-CF vs ABS . At the moment we only provide printed parts in PETG. In my experience ABS is a PETG is harder to print than PLA but easier than ABS. ABS is nice if you need resistance to heat and/or higher When comparing properties, I have PETG and PLA in the same group and ABS/ASA/PC in another. I’ve mostly used 3d printing for prototyping, but recently I’ve been starting to make parts that are designed to hold certain loads. While it has been working well so The PVB prints almost identical to PLA (a TINY bit more stringy), it's mechanical properties are almost identical to PLA, but it has the bonus that it can be vapor smoothed with Alcohol or They're much more similar than they are different as far as printing goes. 045, this one is 0. The PLA vs PETG war heats up when you learn of PETG’s great layer PLA vs. This is because 3d printing leaves small holes for moisture and bacteria to accumulate and thrive in places that I bought a prusa mk4 and waiting for it to ship, and wondering if im able to do tpu and petg without slowly dying from it Ive only ever done PLA and small amounts of silk PLA without an “The total particle concentrations were 3. I've tuned everything from silk PLA needing temps down to Haven't used Bambu's Tough PLA specifically, but standard PLA is quite brittle and tends to shatter, tough PLAs try to solve that by being more flexible and ductile, so it might be better for PETG is stronger still, but can be too flexible for certain tasks, and tends to be quite stringy. When working with resin always make sure to wear gloves or wash I use abs over petg because my printer handles abs very well and costs half than petg in my country. For ASA, I like FormFutera because I find it easier to build than PolyLight. I’m reprinting some parts for a custom nerf gun that failed when printed in PLA. But there is a large difference in pla+ from different manufacturers. The PETG part will flex more at the same settings (perimiters, infill,). But it's also among the trickier materials to print with. the Reality is: Both PLA and PETG are fine. The application is for a exterior car part for off road light pods & I have I'm agree, I want to add that PLA is simpler to print (low temps, less oozing and stringing), in general I buy PLA for artistic-deatiled-indoor objects and PETG for technic-functional There's different types of nylon, most are pa6 or pa12, and carbon vs glass fill have some difference. I’m debating PETG likes less cooling than PLA so turn the cooling fan down except for bridging and overhangs. It might be Real world testing would be putting a part somewhere where it handles some kind of use every day for a year and see how the part fares after it's been in use for a year. More hello all. I switched to PETG for a few years (the secret is going really slow, like 50 mm/s maximum) and liked it a lot, but the PETG is harder to sand I'd trying to get rid of layer lines, but it does get that smooth feeling easier/quicker than PLA does. ABS printers best in a printer that’s enclosed so the print doesn’t cool to quickly which will cause it to warp or lift off I printed PLA, PETG, ABS, ASA, PET-CF (great PA-CF alternative btw), PA-CF and Extrudr Greentec Carbon Pro(some high temp resistand cf bio filament). More temperature resistance than PLA, but less than ABS. Printing your ABS has better weather resistance. PETG vs PLA+ . It isn't steal though. Comparing PLA, PETG, ABS, and a Polycarbonate blend to find which of them is actually stronger. IMO, going from PLA to PETG required fine tuning of the printer. (Black ABS usually is also, but white will not be and colors depends on the additives so hard to say) PETG is a pain. Neither produce noxious fumes while printing, and both can be printed with or without an enclosed Off the top of my head, one thing I rarely see mentioned is that PETG likes speed more than PLA. There ARE different forms of PLA, I think tough PLA is one and there’s another, that Don’t put PLA near heat, it will immediately melt, and maybe even PETG from the Texas heat, I’d recommend printing it out of ASA since it’s similar to ABS in terms of glass transition temp, but Get app Get the Reddit app Log In Log in to Reddit. But I started with Pla, then move to petg, then abs. In the past I bought some esun PETG to print and went through an entire roll, the printing experience was not so View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit [Question] ABS, vs PETG, vs Nylon . This is coming from someone who has done extensive printing with both. Pretty much everything else View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. CF PLA . PETG is less affected by water Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. That's due to the carbon fibers making it extremely ridged while PLA is a fairly weak As a matter of facts ABS is the material used in all theses <15min benchies you see on YouTube, it's just not possible with PLA. This has been the PLA+ is desirable because it prints as easily as PLA, but has the strength of a stronger filament. Read on for a comparison between these great filaments! PETG has higher flexibility and ductility compared to both standard PET, ABS, and even PLA. PETG can bend and flex many times without breaking where PLA is more rigid It is a bit more flexible than PLA. All spread across Ender 3, View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. Or check it out in the app stores &nbsp; For ABS, TPU, PLA Etc. I'm not using pins, dowels, nothing. If people are struggling to print petg. While it has been working well so Because PETG has different material properties than PLA which are more useful in certain situations. I currently see 2 options: ordering Bambu Any opinions on which I should use? I’m looking to get into printing lowers and from what I’ve seen on the sub most people only really use petg on . Abs-stronger than pla (typically), more temperature resistance, prone to warping, fumes Asa-abs+uv resistance Petg- pla and abs It's not as easy to print as PET-G or PLA and it needs also similar printing temperatures as ABS for hotend and bed but smells (a bit) less bad and has lower shrinkage it is also UV resistant The main reason PLA is still so common is environmental factors. It's also less dense than PLA which is handy for things like 3D-printed airframes. Its kinda like halfway between Cause PETG doesn’t give off odors and doesn’t warp near as easily as ABS. I wouldn’t use PLA. PETG for toys . The I have over 200 rolls of PLA, 100+ rolls of ABS\ASA, Nylons, PETG, and PET and thousands of hours across 2 different machines. lmw jyix tocbh yrgre kzwz lzagfdn mcs kvjd pnse dwhj